PHOENIX MACRO | BITCOIN ACCUMULATION SYSTEM
DAY
Back to Learn ← Learn
On-Chain Signals  ·  02

STH MVRV: The Signal That Tells You What Recent Buyers Are Actually Feeling

Phoenix Macro · April 2026 · 12 min read
When short-term holders go underwater, the market enters its most emotionally unstable phase. That instability is where the real accumulation opportunity lives.

There is a number sitting at 0.87 right now. It rarely makes headlines. The mainstream financial press ignores it. For anyone serious about understanding where Bitcoin is in its cycle, it is one of the most honest readings the chain produces.

That number is the STH MVRV. And what it is saying right now is straightforward. The average person who bought Bitcoin in the last few months is sitting on a loss.


What STH MVRV actually measures

MVRV stands for Market Value to Realized Value. In its standard form it measures the ratio between what the entire Bitcoin market is worth today and what every coin on the network was worth when it last moved.

STH MVRV is a more targeted version of that same concept. It filters for only one group of holders - those who acquired Bitcoin within the last 155 days. These are the short-term holders. The recent buyers. The people who entered the market during the most recent phase of activity and have not yet moved their coins again.

The calculation is the same. Market value divided by realized value, but only for that specific group.

STH MVRV above 1.0
Short-term holders are in aggregate profit. Recent buyers are above their cost basis.
STH MVRV below 1.0
Short-term holders are in aggregate loss. Recent buyers are underwater.
Current reading: 0.87
The average short-term holder paid roughly 13% more for their Bitcoin than it is currently worth. The further below 1.0, the deeper the average recent buyer is underwater.

Why recent buyers drive market psychology

Long-term holders are a different psychological category. They have held through multiple cycles. They have already survived drawdowns of 50%, 70%, 80%. Their cost basis is often so low relative to current prices that even a significant correction leaves them comfortably in profit. They are not the ones making panic decisions during a sustained decline.

Short-term holders are different. They bought recently. They do not have years of cycle experience embedded in their conviction. When the market drops below their cost basis, they feel it immediately and personally. The paper loss is not abstract. It is their money, in the red, right now.

This is why STH MVRV is such a precise fear gauge. It does not measure what the whole market is feeling in aggregate. It measures what the most emotionally vulnerable group of participants is holding at this moment.

Long-term holders
Held through multiple cycles. Low cost basis. Psychologically anchored. Not the source of panic selling.
Short-term holders
Bought recently. No cycle experience. Feel losses immediately and personally. The most emotionally vulnerable group of participants.

What it actually feels like to be a short-term holder right now

The average person captured by an STH MVRV of 0.87 bought Bitcoin somewhere in the last five months. They made a decision. They moved money. They watched the price for a while and it probably felt fine initially. Then it started moving against them. Slowly at first, then more consistently. Now they are sitting on a loss of roughly 13% or more, depending on when they entered.

Research in behavioral economics consistently shows that humans feel the pain of a loss approximately twice as intensely as they feel the pleasure of an equivalent gain. A 13% loss does not feel like a 13% loss. It feels significantly worse. And the longer it persists, the more it clouds judgment.

Stage What happens
Rationalization The holder tells themselves the loss is temporary. Bitcoin always recovers. They are long term anyway. This is just noise. That rationalization can hold for weeks, sometimes months - but requires active mental energy to maintain.
Monitoring The person who told themselves they were not watching the price starts watching the price. Every dip confirms their fear. Every small recovery raises hope and then fails to follow through. The emotional bandwidth consumed is significant.
Threshold decision A specific price level becomes the line. The exact trigger is almost arbitrary. What is not arbitrary: when the decision to sell comes, it feels like relief rather than failure. The removal of uncertainty feels better than the continuation of pain. That relief is the supply that gets transferred to the next holder.

This is not weakness. This is human neurology responding to financial stress in a completely predictable way. Without a system, the only tool available is pure feeling.

What the data from early 2026 shows is that this process has been happening in waves rather than in a single panic event. Short-term holders have been realizing losses gradually and consistently. The selling has been controlled rather than explosive. That pattern of gradual capitulation is actually more psychologically exhausting for those still holding than a sharp crash would be. A crash ends. A slow grind through your cost basis with no clear resolution creates the kind of sustained uncertainty that weakens conviction most effectively.

The people who make it through that grind intact - who keep deploying systematically while the STH MVRV sits below 1.0 - are not special. They just made a decision before the conditions got hard. That decision is what a system is for.


What the historical record shows

Historically, readings below 1.0 have clustered around two types of market conditions. The first is late-stage bear markets and capitulation events, where short-term holders have been underwater long enough that the weakest hands have already sold and the remaining ones are either committed or trapped. The second is mid-cycle corrections within broader bull structures, where a period of overextension gets corrected sharply enough to push recent buyers briefly into loss before the trend resumes.

Both of those environments share one characteristic. They are uncomfortable. The price action is negative or flat. Sentiment is poor. The narrative in the market is either cautious or outright bearish.

That psychological pressure is what produces the supply that long-term accumulators absorb. Sellers emerge not because the fundamentals have changed but because the discomfort of holding an underwater position eventually exceeds the conviction that brought them in.

When STH MVRV is above 1.0 and rising, that pressure does not exist. Recent buyers are in profit. There is no urgency to sell. The supply available to patient accumulators is limited and expensive. When STH MVRV drops below 1.0, that dynamic reverses. Supply becomes available. Prices reflect distress rather than value.


The difference between 0.87 and 0.60

A reading of 0.87 is meaningful but it is not the extreme end of the range. In the deepest capitulation events Bitcoin has experienced, STH MVRV has dropped significantly lower. During the 2022 bear market lows it fell well below 0.60 as short-term holders absorbed losses that were far more severe than what the current reading reflects.

Current: 0.87
Short-term holders under pressure. Market in a stressed phase. Average recent buyer is 13% underwater.
2022 lows: below 0.60
Maximum capitulation territory. Losses far more severe. The deepest short-term holder pain Bitcoin has produced.

This matters for how the signal is interpreted in context. At 0.87, short-term holders are under pressure but not at maximum pain. The reading tells you the market is in a stressed phase, not necessarily that it has found its floor. It is one signal pointing in a clear direction. What the other seven signals say alongside it determines how the overall picture is read.

When STH MVRV sits below 1.0 while NUPL is compressed in the hope/fear zone, while SOPR is printing below 1.0, while the Mayer Multiple approaches 0.80, the convergence tells a coherent story. The market is under stress across multiple dimensions simultaneously. That kind of alignment is what the IA Score is designed to capture and translate into a weekly deployment decision.


What 0.87 means for the accumulator

Recent buyers are uncomfortable. The group most likely to sell into weakness is holding losses and making decisions under pressure. The supply side of the market is more emotionally driven right now than it was six months ago when this same group was in profit and had no urgency to move.

The chain does not lie about who is in pain. At 0.87, it is telling you clearly.

For the long-term accumulator with a framework, that information is not a reason to hesitate. It is what the framework was built to read.

← Previous 01 · MVRV-Z Score Explained Next → 03 · SOPR and When Holders Capitulate
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.